BOOK: FANTASY (ages 8-12)
Brief Description: Orphan Frederick is a good boy who does what he's told. When he is "adopted" to be a servant in the wizard Lord Schofield's home, he unwittingly brings along a mischievous brownie named Billy Bly. When a dark curse appears at the home, and although Lord Schofield doesn't permit such creatures in his home, Billy Bly saves the day along with Frederick.
Awards: None
Personal Opinion: Didn't like it at all. This book was boring, lackluster and not a bit interesting. I think it had potential, but just fell short as the plot dragged considerably. There was not enough suspense to keep me interested, and it seemed there was much repetition. The characters were okay, but not completely compelling or authentic. I thought the actions of the characters were out of "character" and were really all over the place. Some may enjoy this story, but it simply didn't click for me at all.
Curriculum/Programming: I wouldn't use this book with students unless they were learning about sluggish plot structures and inauthentic characters; this book would then be a good example.
No comments:
Post a Comment